The Social Security dilemma may result in American retirees facing greater hardships than seniors in less affluent nations

America’s Social Security Faces a Looming Crisis

For decades, the financial stability of Social Security has been under threat, and the situation is now reaching a critical point.

My father immigrated from Ecuador, and with the current state of Social Security, I sometimes wonder if returning there would be a better option.

Recently, I was stunned to learn that within the next ten years, the average Social Security payment in the United States could fall below what retirees receive in several less affluent nations—including Ecuador, Colombia, Jordan, and Poland.

Trending on MarketWatch

At this rate, retirees in the U.S. may soon find themselves only slightly ahead of those in countries like Greece, Turkey, Estonia, and Montenegro.

This is a sobering reality.

The alarming projections come directly from the Social Security Administration and a recent study by Moorepay, a payroll services provider.

According to Social Security’s own estimates, if nothing changes, benefits will be cut by 19% in just eight years when the trust funds are depleted.

Moorepay’s research shows that the average annual Social Security benefit is around $23,500. Even now, American retirees receive less than their peers in over a dozen developed countries, such as Italy, Germany, and most Scandinavian nations. The deep reductions expected in 2034 would push the U.S. even further down the global rankings.

The funding shortfall has been building for three decades, but the situation has worsened as the federal government’s finances have deteriorated. Back in 2000, during Bill Clinton’s final year in office, the government posted a surplus equal to 2.3% of GDP. This surplus allowed for debt reduction and increased the government’s ability to support Social Security in the future.

However, subsequent tax cuts, the financial crisis, and the COVID-19 pandemic have led to massive deficits. Today, the federal deficit exceeds 6% of GDP, and the national debt has more than tripled as a share of the economy, approaching levels not seen since the aftermath of World War II.

Moorepay’s analysis compares average state pension incomes worldwide, using both currency exchange rates and “purchasing-power parity” to reflect real buying power. Many countries outside the U.S. offer lower living costs for retirees, making their benefits stretch further.

What Happens If Nothing Changes?

If current laws remain in place, Social Security would be forced to reduce all benefits to about 81% of their current value, according to the trustees. However, many experts believe the cuts would likely focus on higher-income recipients, a direction even some Republican lawmakers support.

It’s alarming to realize that Social Security could reach insolvency in just eight years, though experts have been warning about this for years. Despite these warnings, recent government actions have included modest increases in Social Security spending and the passage of another large tax cut, hoping these measures might somehow help.

Such moves are akin to a ship’s captain trying to save a sinking vessel by drilling more holes in the hull, hoping the water will drain out.

Moorepay’s report did not cover Venezuela’s retirement system. If retirees there start receiving payments in digital currencies like $TRUMP TRUMPUSD or $MELANIA MELANIAUSD, we’ll be sure to report it. After all, what happens in Caracas may not stay in Caracas.

More Popular Reads from MarketWatch